Skip to main content

what makes a sermon successful?

Have a couple posts on preaching rolling around in my head. Will post more this week. I just finished Andy Stanley's Communicating for a Change. It's deepening the growth, challenge and reward I find in being a communicator. Book notes & reflection coming.  

Yesterday, I asked my twitter & facebook friends what makes a sermon successful:

@jimthemethodist: connected the congregation with the text through their context in a way that propels them in mission.

@preachinzoogal: if one person is touched by it and learns something, then its successful!

@deb1955: Jen, for me it is one that I am still thinking about beyond the end of service...whether it makes me smile or squirm.

Daria: For me, good story-telling. Not some overtold story from a sermon helpers subscription, but something really cool and off-the-beaten path. Or a personal story.

Adam: I doubt we can ever know if a sermon is really successful or not...all we can do is pray for receptivity and acceptance in the hearts and minds of those who hear. I listen for solid logical and academic founding, but I also listen for how well the topic can be related to the lives of the listeners.

Jim: The offering?  The conversions afterwards?  When someone who usually says "nice sermon" says, "pastor, I'd really like to talk with you about that sermon today?"  When you get to the end of it and you realize that it really wasn't just you in the pulpit that day but that God was really moving and you were along for the ride?  When it affects how you and the congregation approach Monday morning or the next year?

@InHzService: when people leave discussing and affected by the message contained in the sermon...not the sermon itself; inspires action

@mattkelley468: one that challenges people, makes them think, and makes them be more in awe of god 

@bennettvt: when folks connect with the text in a new way, that helps them live out their story as part of God's Story

Tamara: short and to the point

Jim: frequently ... we never know ... but faithfully ... we keep offering our best

Kelly: humor



What do you think?


jimmorrow said…
I like Tamara's.
guy m williams said…
Thanks for asking the question and sharing the conversation so far.

I think your original post captured a huge criteria for a sermon being labeled "successful": producing life change.

I have Andy Stanley's book on my "soon" list and look forward to your reflections. His leadership podcast on preaching/communication is very good.

Preaching for me is basically spiritual formation in a corporate setting. So, it is successful if it advances individual and/or communal formation in Christ. I think this is captured in your point about life change, but it describes it a little more specifically, in reference to persons who are already Christians at least. For outreach/evangelism either in or as the whole focus of the sermon, spiritual formation is still the end goal, but the approach would fit the audience.

I think it is helpful to consider both outcome and input criteria.

Life change (on both individual and corporate levels) is an outcome type of criteria.

An input type of criteria for me is preaching in a way that evidences some transparency about my thinking process when engaging the biblical text and theological reflection. I don't want to overload the teaching aspect, but we are modeling biblical interpretation and theological reflection in the sermon, so some intentionality about how we are arriving at our basic point is important to me. The same can be said of how we engage culture, etc. You can extrapolate from here.

Also, Adam Hamilton has an excellent point on the purposes of a sermon in his Unleashing the Word.
Lilly said…
As sermon-giver, I think success or failure is determined by your willingness to allow the Word of God to move through you. Did you humble yourself and allow God to speak? Do you trust God to move the people or are you relying on your own innovative genius?
As a sermon-receiver, the sermons that have been the most meaningful were "This is the Way, walk in it" (Isaiah 30:21b) sermons. Or you could say they were teachings on absolute Truth. Those sermons pierce me, humble me, and cause me to cry out to God in passionate worship.

Most Read

Why Some Experienced Clergy (and Lay People) Have a Hard Time When Younger Clergy Take Renewal Leave

This is a guest post from my very own dad! He's a United Methodist pastor serving in Bend, Oregon. I enjoy chatting church leadership with my dad and it's fascinating to see how our generational differences bring different perspectives to our calling as pastor. We need each generation to walk with each other as we figure it out in this new world. We've been reflecting lately as I finished up a renewal leave and he prepares to retire this June. 
By David Beckett
I fall into the category of experienced clergy which is a polite way of saying I am old. I’ve been pastoring for nearly 40 years. When I was a young pastor my role models were mostly white males who presented an image of success that equated with dedication, overwork, and sacrifice. My first senior pastor talked about the 20 hr/wk he invested in sermon preparation. And he expected his staff to work beyond their stated hours. During those three years of full time seminary and a large youth group I put in up to 80 hr/…

Why pastors need collaboration, not competition

There's competition in every industry. Some get promoted over others. Some work incredibly hard but their gifts go unnoticed. Others do good work and people assume they're fine but underneath, they feel like they could never be honest about how hard life is in this season. People spend more energy figuring out how they measure up in a work culture instead of doing the actual work.

Competition itself implies there are two sides.

I remember field days at my elementary school in Alaska. The half-frozen spring ground was covered with clumps of dirty gray snow. Jackets were thrown on the ground as the fourth graders tried to beat the fifth graders at tug of war. Rope burns were shrugged off as sweat dripped down our young faces. We were determined to beat those fifth graders. Our pride was on the line.

Whether you're a fourth grader or an ad manager at a fancy marketing agency or a senator trying out for attorney general, competition runs deep in our DNA.

We want to be the bes…

Why I stay in the United Methodist Church

We can't ignore the numbers. The United Methodist Church is in decline. Many ask, "Why do you stay? Denominations are useless these days."

But I face that reality with overwhelming hope and excitement. I see the Holy Spirit weaving its way through our current & new leadership in ways I've only dreamed of. A couple years ago, I thought about leaving. But I decided to ask some hard questions about why we're in decline. And that journey to the heart of the United Methodist movement has lit a fire in me to see it renewed.

Why I Stay...

1. Our faith is active. We get our hands and hearts dirty in service & relationships.
2. Every United Methodist church is connected through a network of gatherings, prayer, service, money, agencies and leadership. I would never want to serve in building God's kingdom by myself.
3. I see God changing hearts and lives every. single. day.
4. I am fascinated by our founder who's only intention was to create a renewal movement ins…